Three Misconceptions about the Safety Integrity Level (SIL)
An often misunderstood core element of functional safety
The Safety Integrity Level, or SIL for short, is an indicator that makes risk reduction quantifiable
Plant and machinery can pose risks that are so dangerous that people and the environment should not be exposed to them under any circumstances. If such a hazard exists, the associated risks must be mitigated to meet the need for safety.
The Safety Integrity Level, or SIL for short, is an indicator that makes risk reduction quantifiable. SIL is a core element of functional safety - and simultaneously the object of many misconceptions. Pepperl+Fuchs clarifies three of the most common misunderstandings.
Misconception 1: SIL is a device characteristic
Misconception 2: SIL 3 is automatically the better choice compared to SIL 2
The SIL rating required depends on the initial risk inherent to the plant's systems or processes. The following applies: The residual risk remaining after risk reduction must be lower than the tolerable risk. If this is achievable with SIL 2, then the installation of a SIL 3 protective device could, in some circumstances, be too much of a good thing.
The over-fulfillment of a SIL can result in unnecessary effort and avoidable cost, much the same as over-insurance in the private sector is unnecessarily expensive and a waste of money. The aim is to design the protective device so that the risk reduction it achieves corresponds as closely as possible to the required SIL.
Misconception 3: Considering the probability of a system failure is sufficient with regard to SIL
Quantifying the failure probability of a protective device is not sufficient to fulfill a Safety Integrity Level. Primary measures for the prevention and control of faults must be implemented to this end. The relevant standard requires, first and foremost, the application of a special quality management system (Functional Safety Management System).
In addition, failure control by means such as redundancy, fail-safe behavior, and fault detection (diagnostics) are mandatory. The extent to which these measures need to be applied depends on the targeted SIL.
Pepperl+Fuchs Inc.
1600 Enterprise Parkway
Twinsburg, OH 44087
United States of America
sales@us.pepperl-fuchs.com
+1 330 425-3555
Pepperl+Fuchs is a leading developer and manufacturer of electronic sensors and components for the global automation market. Continuous innovation, enduring quality, and steady growth have been the foundation of our success for more than 70 years. Pepperl+Fuchs employs 6,300 people worldwide and has manufacturing facilities in Germany, USA, Singapore, Hungary, Indonesia and Vietnam, most of them ISO 9001 certified. Pepperl+Fuchs does not sell personal data.